Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
You can decide: Germany by Kristo1594 You can decide: Germany by Kristo1594
Okay, here's my first YCD.
I tried to put a lot of possibilities in it, but of course it's not possibil to get them all.
Please vote from 1 to 10. 1 means "No, that's totally not Germany" and 10 means "Yes, this is part of Germany and this will never change".

It's over. Result -> <da:thumb id="435683365">
Add a Comment:
 
:iconjerry7119:
Jerry7119 Featured By Owner Aug 19, 2014
It's very well done. I wonder how did you create the borders so exactly.
Reply
:iconjjohnson1701:
JJohnson1701 Featured By Owner Jul 2, 2014
1 Northern Schleswig 3
2 Bornholm 1
3 Memel/Klaipeda 10
4 Southern Schleswig 10
5 Holstein 10
6 Mecklenburg 10
7 Western Pomerania 10
8 Eastern Pomerania 10
9 West Prussia 10
10 East Prussia 10
11 Hanover 10
12 Saxony-Anhalt 10
13 West Brandenburg 10
14 East Brandenburg 10
15 Posen/Poznan 10
16 Limburg 5 (Eupen/Malmedy yes, Limburg, don't care either way)
17 Northern Rhineland 10
18 Westphalia 10
19 Hesse 10
20 Thuringia 10
21 Saxony 10
22 Görlitz 10
23 Lower Silesia 10
24 Oppeln/Opole 10
25 Upper Silesia 10
26 Belgian Luxembourg 1
27 Luxembourg 1
28 Southern Rhineland 10
29 Bavarian Rhineland 10
30 Lorraine 10
31 Alsace 10
32 Baden 10
33 Württemberg 10
34 Frankonia 10
35 Bavaria 10
36 Bohemia 1
37 Moravia 1
38 Ostrau/Ostrava 10
39 Bielitz-Biala/Bielsko-Biala 10
40 Austria 10
41 Northern Tyrol 10
42 Salzburg 10
43 Styria 10
44 South Tyrol 10
45 Trent/Trentino 1
46 Kärnten 10
47 Slowenian Styria 10
+1 Sudetenland 10
+2 Burgenland-Sopron 10
A Expansion into Scandinavia 1
B Expansion into the Netherlands and Belgium 1
C Expansion into East Europe 1
D Expamsion into France and Switzerland 1
E Expansion into Southeast Europe (especially former Austrian territories) 1

No to A through E
Reply
:icondisstrack:
Disstrack Featured By Owner Jun 20, 2014
Sehr schwierige Aufgabe... kann mich nicht entscheiden, nehm ich jetzt nur Kaiserreich und Luxemburg, oder nehm ich die zurauswahlstehenden teile von Österreich-Ungarn dazu.....
PS.: die Deutschschweiz wäre auch eine gute auswahlmöglichkeit
Reply
:iconlumi-natis:
Lumi-Natis Featured By Owner Jan 6, 2014
Here it is:
+1 Sudetenland 10
+2 Burgenland-Sopron 9
Reply
:iconarminius1871:
Arminius1871 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
1+ Sudetenland 10
2+ Burgenland/ Sopron 10
Reply
:iconbeastboss:
Beastboss Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Photographer
+1 Sudetenland-9
+2 Burgenland-Sopron-7
Reply
:iconcheetaaaaa:
Cheetaaaaa Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
1 Northern Schleswig 5/10
2 Bornholm 1/10
3 Memel/Klaipeda 1/10
4 Southern Schleswig 10/10
5 Holstein 10/10
6 Mecklenburg 10/10
7 Western Pomerania 10/10
8 Eastern Pomerania 10/10
9 West Prussia 1/10
10 East Prussia 10/10
11 Hanover 10/10
12 Saxony-Anhalt 10/10
13 West Brandenburg 10/10
14 East Brandenburg 10/10
15 Posen/Poznan 1/10
16 Limburg 6/10
17 Northern Rhineland 10/10
18 Westphalia 10/10
19 Hesse 10/10
20 Thuringia 10/10
21 Saxony 10/10
22 Görlitz 10/10
23 Lower Silesia 10/10
24 Oppeln/Opole 10/10
25 Upper Silesia 10/10
26 Belgian Luxembourg 1/10
27 Luxembourg 6/10
28 Southern Rhineland 10/10
29 Bavarian Rhineland 10/10
30 Lorraine 5/10
31 Alsace 10/10
32 Baden 10/10
33 Württemberg 10/10
34 Frankonia 10/10
35 Bavaria 10/10
36 Bohemia 1/10
37 Moravia 1/10
38 Ostrau/Ostrava 1/10
39 Bielitz-Biala/Bielsko-Biala 1/10
40 Austria 1/10
41 Northern Tyrol 1/10
42 Salzburg 1/10
43 Styria 1/10
44 South Tyrol 1/10
45 Trent/Trentino 1/10
46 Kärnten 1/10
47 Slowenian Styria 1/10
A Expansion into Scandinavia 1/10
B Expansion into the Netherlands and Belgium 1/10
C Expansion into East Europe 1/10
D Expamsion into France and Switzerland 1/10
E Expansion into Southeast Europe (especially former Austrian territories) 1/10
Reply
:iconcheetaaaaa:
Cheetaaaaa Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014

+1 Sudetenland 7/10

+2 Burgenland-Sopron 1/10

Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Add Sudetenland as "+1" and Burgenland-Sopron as "+2", please vote :)
Reply
:iconcheetaaaaa:
Cheetaaaaa Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
Ich spreche Deutsch, wenn du dich erinnerst. ;)
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
ja das war einfach nur copypasta^^
Reply
:iconspiritswriter123:
Spiritswriter123 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
I'm surprised you didn't add Eupen-Malmedy, Sudetenland or Sopron as choosable areas. Any ways

1 Northern Schleswig: 3
2 Bornholm: 1
3 Memel/Klaipeda: 3
4 Southern Schleswig: 8
5 Holstein: 10
6 Mecklenburg: 10
7 Western Pomerania: 10
8 Eastern Pomerania: 9
9 West Prussia: 5
10 East Prussia: 7
11 Hanover: 10
12 Saxony-Anhalt: 10
13 West Brandenburg: 10
14 East Brandenburg: 9
15 Posen/Poznan: 2
16 Limburg: 4
17 Northern Rhineland: 9
18 Westphalia: 10
19 Hesse: 10
20 Thuringia: 10
21 Saxony: 10
22 Görlitz: 10
23 Lower Silesia: 7
24 Oppeln/Opole: 5
25 Upper Silesia: 4
26 Belgian Luxembourg: 3
27 Luxembourg: 6
28 Southern Rhineland: 9
29 Bavarian Rhineland: 9
30 Lorraine: 3
31 Alsace: 6
32 Baden: 10
33 Württemberg: 10
34 Frankonia: 10
35 Bavaria: 10
36 Bohemia: 3
37 Moravia: 2
38 Ostrau/Ostrava: 2
39 Bielitz-Biala/Bielsko-Biala: 1
40 Austria: 9
41 Northern Tyrol: 9
42 Salzburg: 9
43 Styria: 9
44 South Tyrol: 8
45 Trent/Trentino: 3
46 Kärnten: 8
47 Slowenian Styria: 2
A Expansion into Scandinavia: 1
B Expansion into the Netherlands and Belgium: 2
C Expansion into East Europe: 1
D Expamsion into France and Switzerland: 3
E Expansion into Southeast Europe (especially former Austrian territories): 1

(if you do decide to add Sudatenland, Sopron, and Eupen-Malmedy, here are my scores
Suadenland: 7
Sopron: 5
Eupen-Malmedy: 9)
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
yeah maybe you understand that I had to choose.
I think nobody would like to vote 90 or 100 provinces ^^;
Reply
:iconspiritswriter123:
Spiritswriter123 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
I understand, but seeing you added them anyway, okay.
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
yeah because many other also asked for sudetenland and Sopron^^
Reply
:iconnocturnaldarkness:
NocturnalDarkness Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
I'd like to contribute, but there seems to be no context to it. Is it meant to be reward or punishment? Does it take place in any particular timeframe that would affect my choices (e.g. 1848, 1918, 1945)?
Reply
:iconnocturnaldarkness:
NocturnalDarkness Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2014
Hmm. Well, I've always considered the German heartland to be between the Rhine and the Elbe, so...
5, 11, 12, 18, 19, 20, 21, 32, 33, 34 and 35. :)

As for expansion, option E.

Hope that's satisfactory. :)
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
No there's no timeframe. It's all up to you. You can decide if Germany should gain back some of the lost land or if it's to big at the moment and maybe bavaria should be independent so it's no part of Germany. It's all about your personal preferences, thoughts and knowledge^^
Reply
:iconklausvonkueste:
KlausVonKueste Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
1 - 4
2 - 3
3 - 9
4,5,6,7 - 10
8 - 9
9,10,11,12,13,14 - 10
15 - 9
16 - 4
17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25 - 10
26 - 4
27 - 9
28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35 - 10
36,37 - 7
38,39 - 9
40,41,42,43 - 10
44 - 8
45 - 5
46 - 10
47 - 8
Reply
:iconklausvonkueste:
KlausVonKueste Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2014
1+ Sudetenland 10
2+ Burgenland/ Sopron 10
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
BTW you forgot to vote A to E ;)
Reply
:iconklausvonkueste:
KlausVonKueste Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2014

The expansions? To east!

the other expansions only for expand the German culture but not military or other

Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
so?
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Add Sudetenland as "+1" and Burgenland-Sopron as "+2", please vote :)
Reply
:iconklausvonkueste:
KlausVonKueste Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2014
I just do it! all 10 :)
Reply
:iconlumi-natis:
Lumi-Natis Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
1 Northern Schleswig 10
2 Bornholm 7
3 Memel/Klaipeda 10
4 Southern Schleswig 10
5 Holstein 1O
6 Mecklenburg 10
7 Western Pomerania 10
8 Eastern Pomerania 10
9 West Prussia 10
10 East Prussia 10
11 Hanover 10
12 Saxony-Anhalt 10
13 West Brandenburg 10
14 East Brandenburg 10
15 Posen/Poznan 10
16 Limburg 5
17 Northern Rhineland 10
18 Westphalia 10
19 Hesse 10
20 Thuringia 10
21 Saxony 10
22 Görlitz 10
23 Lower Silesia 10
24 Oppeln/Opole 10
25 Upper Silesia 10
26 Belgian Luxembourg 0
27 Luxembourg 5
28 Southern Rhineland 10
29 Bavarian Rhineland 10
30 Lorraine 0
31 Alsace 10
32 Baden 10
33 Württemberg 10
34 Frankonia 10
35 Bavaria 10
36 Bohemia 5
37 Moravia 5
38 Ostrau/Ostrava  10
39 Bielitz-Biala/Bielsko-Biala  10
40 Austria 8
41 Northern Tyrol 8
42 Salzburg 8
43 Styria 8
44 South Tyrol 8
45 Trent/Trentino 7
46 Kärnten 8
47 Slowenian Styria 7
A Expansion into Scandinavia 0
B Expansion into the Netherlands and Belgium: Netherlands 6 Belgium 3
C Expansion into East Europe 6
D Expamsion into France and Switzerland: France 0 Switzerland 5
E Expansion into Southeast Europe (especially former Austrian territories) 0
Reply
:iconarminius1871:
Arminius1871 Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Expansion into France: 9999999999 AHAHAHAH XD
Don´t forget with Lothringen we don´t mean what French see as Lorraine,
but what was the Reichsland Elsass-Lothringen, which is smaller than the
historical Lothringen and had 70% german settled territory.
Reply
:iconlumi-natis:
Lumi-Natis Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2014
On the map what is called lothringen corresponds to the whole Moselle (57) department, with metz and such.
Reply
:iconarminius1871:
Arminius1871 Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Lothringen is 30, there is no 57 oO
Yes that´s why I split it in 7/10, maybe 6/10.

www.lothringen-tourist.info/de…

The green part is german, so 0/10 would not be fair^^
Reply
:iconlumi-natis:
Lumi-Natis Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2014
57 was the french administrative number XD.
About the green part yes,but so poorly populated...
And I put 0 because the "Lorraine" region includes also french parts, so more than 0 wouldn't be fair neither. The best would have been to split it between german and french part.
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Add Sudetenland as "+1" and Burgenland-Sopron as "+2", please vote :)
Reply
:iconlumi-natis:
Lumi-Natis Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
I don't get it? ^^ Do you mean you added 2 other places?
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
jupp and the numbers are +1 and +2 xD
Reply
:iconlumi-natis:
Lumi-Natis Featured By Owner Jan 6, 2014
ok ok
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Oh, and I wish you had used some more historical province than just mostly the modern states. For example, I would gladly "let you keep" Saxony but it has Lausitz XD
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
hmm yes I had to chose I think nobody would answer if there are 90 or 100 optionsSweating a little... 
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That's completely understandable ^_^ .  .  .  BUT I WANT MY LAUSITZ! O_O
:XD:
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
xD 
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I admit I was a little biased, sorry ^^; But thanks for the great idea :D

1 Northern Schleswig - 3

2 Bornholm - 5
3 Memel/Klaipeda - 7
4 Southern Schleswig - 5
5 Holstein - 8
6 Mecklenburg - 10
7 Western Pomerania - 10
8 Eastern Pomerania - 10
9 West Prussia - 10
10 East Prussia - 10
11 Hanover - 10
12 Saxony-Anhalt - 10
13 West Brandenburg - 10
14 East Brandenburg - 8
15 Posen/Poznan - 7
16 Limburg - 4
17 Northern Rhineland - 10
18 Westphalia - 10
19 Hesse - 10
20 Thuringia - 10
21 Saxony - 4
22 Görlitz - 1
23 Lower Silesia - 1
24 Oppeln/Opole - 1
25 Upper Silesia - 1
26 Belgian Luxembourg - 3
27 Luxembourg - 3
28 Southern Rhineland - 10
29 Bavarian Rhineland - 10
30 Lorraine - 8
31 Alsace - 8
32 Baden - 10
33 Württemberg - 10
34 Frankonia - 6
35 Bavaria - 8
36 Bohemia - 1
37 Moravia - 1
38 Ostrau/Ostrava - 1
39 Bielitz-Biala/Bielsko-Biala - 1
40 Austria - 8
41 Northern Tyrol - 8
42 Salzburg - 8
43 Styria - 8
44 South Tyrol - 8
45 Trent/Trentino - 7
46 Kärnten - 8
47 Slowenian Styria - 7
A Expansion into Scandinavia - 3
B Expansion into the Netherlands and Belgium - 5
C Expansion into East Europe - 3
D Expamsion into France and Switzerland - 5
E Expansion into Southeast Europe (especially former Austrian territories) - 5
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Add Sudetenland as "+1" and Burgenland-Sopron as "+2", please vote :)
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
+1 Sudetenland - 1
+2 Burgenland-Sopron - 7
Reply
:iconcheetaaaaa:
Cheetaaaaa Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
You're hurting my feelings! D:
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Whaaaa? ;A;
Reply
:iconcheetaaaaa:
Cheetaaaaa Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
You think Austria should be added to Germany!
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I don't! ;A; I was just saying that it is more German than Bohemia. I have always been bad at this 1-10 scale stuff >:S 
Reply
:iconcheetaaaaa:
Cheetaaaaa Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
You're certainly right about that, but 7/10 is a bit much, don't you think?
Reply
:iconsoaringaven:
SoaringAven Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I said I am bad at this -_- I give a score 6-8 to all my dad's food no matter what.
Reply
:iconfederalrepublic:
FederalRepublic Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
Note: I base this on personal preference and historical (pre-WW1) demographics and (lack of certain) national identities. Today Germany's size is perfectly fine considering the current situation.

1 Northern Schleswig - [8]

2 Bornholm - [1]
3 Memel/Klaipeda - [8]
4 Southern Schleswig - [9]
5 Holstein - [10]
6 Mecklenburg - [10]
7 Western Pomerania - [10]
8 Eastern Pomerania - [10]
9 West Prussia - [9]
10 East Prussia - [10]
11 Hanover - [10]
12 Saxony-Anhalt - [10]
13 West Brandenburg - [10]
14 East Brandenburg - [10]
15 Posen/Poznan - [8]
16 Limburg - [3]
17 Northern Rhineland - [10]
18 Westphalia - [10]
19 Hesse - [10]
20 Thuringia - [10]
21 Saxony - [10]
22 Görlitz - [10]
23 Lower Silesia - [10]
24 Oppeln/Opole - [10]
25 Upper Silesia - [9]
26 Belgian Luxembourg - [3]
27 Luxembourg - [7]
28 Southern Rhineland - [10]
29 Bavarian Rhineland - [10]
30 Lorraine - [7]
31 Alsace - [8]
32 Baden - [10]
33 Württemberg - [10]
34 Franconia - [10]
35 Bavaria - [9]
36 Bohemia - [5]
37 Moravia - [5]
38 Ostrau/Ostrava - [7]
39 Bielitz-Biala/Bielsko-Biala - [7]
40 Austria - [8]
41 Northern Tyrol - [8]
42 Salzburg - [9]
43 Styria - [8]
44 South Tyrol - [8]
45 Trent/Trentino - [3]
46 Caranthinia - [8]
47 Slovenian Styria - [7]
A Expansion into Scandinavia - [1]
B Expansion into the Netherlands and Belgium - [2]
C Expansion into East Europe - [6]
D Expamsion into France and Switzerland - [4]
E Expansion into Southeast Europe (especially former Austrian territories) - [6]
Reply
:iconkristo1594:
Kristo1594 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Add Sudetenland as "+1" and Burgenland-Sopron as "+2", please vote :)
Reply
:iconfederalrepublic:
FederalRepublic Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014
+1 Sudetenland - [9]
+2 Burgenland-Sopron - [7]
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×
Download PNG 1224 × 792



Details

Submitted on
January 2, 2014
Image Size
117 KB
Resolution
1224×792
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
919
Favourites
15 (who?)
Comments
68
Downloads
22
×